Why You Should Stop “Gilding the Lily” at Work
By SalaryFor.com – real salaries for all professions
In Shakespeare’s King John, the original sentiment was clear: to paint the lily or throw perfume on the violet is “wasteful and ridiculous excess.” In the modern workplace, we call this Gilding the Lily—the act of obsessively polishing a task that is already finished, functional, and effective.
While the desire for excellence is admirable, there is a sharp tipping point where “better” becomes the enemy of “done.”
The Law of Diminishing Returns
In productivity, effort and output do not always have a linear relationship. This is best illustrated by the S-Curve of Productivity.
- The Ascent: You put in the initial effort to build the foundation.
- The Plateau: You reach the “90% mark” where the task is high-quality and meets all requirements.
- The Gilding Phase: You spend hours tweaking fonts, rephrasing sentences that already work, or adding “nice-to-have” features that no one asked for.
At this third stage, you are investing 80% more effort for a mere 1% gain in value.
Why We Do It (and Why It’s Dangerous)
Gilding the lily usually isn’t about the work itself; it’s about the psychology of the worker.
- Fear of Judgment: We keep polishing because we’re afraid that “good” isn’t enough to protect us from criticism.
- Procrastination by “Productivity”: It’s easier to spend three hours color-coding a spreadsheet than it is to start the next daunting project on the list.
- Loss of Objective: We lose sight of the purpose of the task (e.g., communicating data) and focus on the aesthetics of the task.
The Danger: When you over-polish one task, you are effectively stealing time and energy from your other responsibilities. It leads to burnout and missed deadlines for projects that actually need your attention.
How to Stop Before You Start Painting Flowers
To avoid the trap of unnecessary perfection, try implementing these three “Stop Loss” strategies:
1. Define “Done” at the Start
Before you open a document, list the criteria for success.
- Does the client need to understand the logic? Yes.
- Do they need custom animations on every slide? No. Once you hit your pre-defined criteria, close the file.
2. The 80/20 Rule (Pareto Principle)
Recognize that 80% of your results come from 20% of your efforts. Focus on the core substance. If the substance is solid, the extra “flair” is often just noise.
3. Time-Boxing
Give yourself a “Polishing Window.” Tell yourself: “I have 15 minutes to make this look pretty, and then I am hitting send.” This creates an artificial scarcity of time that forces you to prioritize meaningful edits over trivial ones.
Summary: The Value of “Good Enough”
In a high-stakes environment, “good enough” isn’t a sign of laziness; it’s a sign of strategic prioritization.
A lily is already beautiful. A report that clearly answers a question is already successful. Adding gold leaf to either won’t make them perform their function any better—it just makes them heavier and more expensive to produce.
Learn to trust your first draft of excellence.
click here for more salary information
In: On The Job Advice · Tagged with: perfectionist trap
